Another Headgasket Bites the dust!

**cantfind1** · 12-07-2010, 08:37 PM

Yep its true!

Got it leak tested today and its leaking between cylinders 1 and 2 didn t bother testing the others as no need.

Will see what it looks like when it comes off.

So I had the same symptoms as Bromers and Shimmy, Replacing fuel Pump, Fuel relay and fuel filter did improve the rough running dramatically but something was still not right!

So while its off will have the injectors cleaned, new water pump, rads cleaned, water temp sensors, knock sensor, ARP head bolts, valves shimmed and have the valves re seated.

I can t wait for the Bill!!

Moral of the story, seems that there are a lot of head gasket issues at the moment, if you are concerned about rough running get the engine leak tested.

Not sure what's causing these HG issues as my car has no history of running hot on oil or water temps, however I do believe it has been running lean due to the fuel pump pressure, will see what the report says about the injectors.

shane@mbtech · 12-07-2010, 08:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cantfind1

Yep its true!

Got it leak tested today and its leaking between cylinders 1 and 2 didn t bother testing the others as no need.

Will see what it looks like when it comes off.

So I had the same symptoms as Bromers and Shimmy, Replacing fuel Pump, Fuel relay and fuel filter did improve the rough running dramatically but something was still not right!

So while its off will have the injectors cleaned, new water pump, rads cleaned, water temp sensors, knock sensor, and have the valves re seated.

I can t wait for the Bill!!

Moral of the story, seems that there are a lot of head gasket issues at the moment, if you are concerned about rough running get the engine leak tested.

Not sure what's causing these HG issues as my car has no history of running hot on oil or water temps, however I do believe it has been running lean due to the fuel pump pressure, will see what the report says about the injectors.

Sorry to hear this

A lot of cars with remaps seem to be having head gasket issues.
Possible link maybe, who knows. This is one reason I am reluctant to re-map, I just have a gut feeling.

Hope you sort it out and does not cost you the earth.

Are you fitting an uprated hg?

XKaLiBaR · 12-07-2010, 08:58 PM

Bad news mate!

Roughly how much will the bill be? Who is doing the work?

**cantfind1** · 12-07-2010, 09:02 PM

Hey Lawsy, I know what you are saying mate but I have had this problem before the remap I just didn t know it!

Car has been running badly for about a year, sort of started after I did the cams(had standard BMW software on then) so put the rough running down to the cams, then had airbox done and remap made it slightly better but then has started getting worse again. Various things replaced but to no avail except for fuel pump,relay and filter, but still not right, only just thought of doing leak test now after all the HG threads of recent.

So I think my HG is well and truly screwed now since it's been over a year and possibly the head, hopefully not the block as this means engine out!!

I think a lot of guys with standard cars, in fact i know a few already, that are going to have HG probs, stealers and Indies are only just finding out about this as its a bit of a b!tch to diagnose and not the first thing you would think of.

DuncanR · 12-07-2010, 09:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lawsy

Sorry to hear this

A lot of cars with remaps seem to be having head gasket issues.
Possible link maybe, who knows.

+ 1 here ref a remap and HG gone at 62k,

Quote:

Originally Posted by lawsy

This is one reason I am reluctant to re-map, I just have a gut feeling.

+ 1 here again !

**shimmy** · 12-07-2010, 09:35 PM

Mine went at around 65k miles I think

been a couple maps on the car before the HG went for short periods but no signs of det or damage just HG worn out

my gut feeling is that it's accelerated wear and tear with regard to the HG issue. Both DR and my car gave done alot of track miles so some premature ageing no doubt.

**shimmy** · 12-07-2010, 09:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lawsy

Sorry to hear this

A lot of cars with remaps seem to be having head gasket issues.
Possible link maybe, who knows. This is one reason I am reluctant to re-map, I just have a gut feeling.

?

easy to say Lawsy but you could equally of said;

alot of cars with Intrax seem to have HG problems
alot of cars with flaps removed seem to have HG problems
alot of cars with high track miles seem to have HG problems
alot of cars with Recaro front seats seem to have HG problems

if you know what I mean

**glendog74** · 12-07-2010, 09:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shimmy

easy to say Lawsy but you could equally of said;

alot of cars with Intrax seem to have HG problems
alot of cars with flaps removed seem to have HG problems
alot of cars with high track miles seem to have HG problems
alot of cars with Recaro front seats seem to have HG problems

if you know what I mean

Or:

alot of cars with HG seem to have HG problems

XKaLiBaR · 12-07-2010, 09:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shimmy

alot of cars with Recaro front seats seem to have HG problems

Oi

shane@mbtech · 12-07-2010, 10:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shimmy

easy to say Lawsy but you could equally of said;

alot of cars with Intrax seem to have HG problems
alot of cars with flaps removed seem to have HG problems
alot of cars with high track miles seem to have HG problems
alot of cars with Recaro front seats seem to have HG problems

if you know what I mean

If you want to talk bollocks then Yes.

Only one really relevant to HG issues on your list would be the high track miles. The pedant in you might already know this though

.

I know my reasons for being dubious about remaps.

I have been thinking about it a lot lately and to the consequences of such. As it is hard to tell "what caused what", I am merely thinking out loud. The remaps available may be perfectly safe, it still does not stop me being concerned.

It seems there has been a rise in the frequency of hg failures of late, whether that be age/"useage" related is unknown or whether there are external influences is unclear at present, but for the benefit of other csl register members and fellow enthusiasts I am merely bouncing thoughts around in the hope for some intelligent returns.

I take on board the heavy track useage as a major factor though

12-07-2010, 08:37 PM	#1
cantfind1 S5, Sport Off, DSC M-track Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Sydney Australia Posts: 675 Casino cash: $6490	Another Headgasket Bites the dust! Yep its true! Got it leak tested today and its leaking between cylinders 1 and 2 didn t bother testing the others as no need. Will see what it looks like when it comes off. So I had the same symptoms as Bromers and Shimmy, Replacing fuel Pump, Fuel relay and fuel filter did improve the rough running dramatically but something was still not right! So while its off will have the injectors cleaned, new water pump, rads cleaned, water temp sensors, knock sensor, ARP head bolts, valves shimmed and have the valves re seated. I can t wait for the Bill!! Moral of the story, seems that there are a lot of head gasket issues at the moment, if you are concerned about rough running get the engine leak tested. Not sure what's causing these HG issues as my car has no history of running hot on oil or water temps, however I do believe it has been running lean due to the fuel pump pressure, will see what the report says about the injectors. Last edited by cantfind1; 12-07-2010 at 09:18 PM.

12-07-2010, 08:58 PM	#3
XKaLiBaR S3 - On the open road Join Date: Jul 2009 Posts: 112 Casino cash: $1203	Bad news mate! Roughly how much will the bill be? Who is doing the work? __________________

12-07-2010, 09:02 PM	#4
cantfind1 S5, Sport Off, DSC M-track Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Sydney Australia Posts: 675 Casino cash: $6490	Hey Lawsy, I know what you are saying mate but I have had this problem before the remap I just didn t know it! Car has been running badly for about a year, sort of started after I did the cams(had standard BMW software on then) so put the rough running down to the cams, then had airbox done and remap made it slightly better but then has started getting worse again. Various things replaced but to no avail except for fuel pump,relay and filter, but still not right, only just thought of doing leak test now after all the HG threads of recent. So I think my HG is well and truly screwed now since it's been over a year and possibly the head, hopefully not the block as this means engine out!! I think a lot of guys with standard cars, in fact i know a few already, that are going to have HG probs, stealers and Indies are only just finding out about this as its a bit of a b!tch to diagnose and not the first thing you would think of. Last edited by cantfind1; 12-07-2010 at 09:05 PM.

12-07-2010, 09:35 PM	#6
shimmy CSL Register Uber-poster! Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Uk Posts: 14,646 Casino cash: $43909	Mine went at around 65k miles I think been a couple maps on the car before the HG went for short periods but no signs of det or damage just HG worn out my gut feeling is that it's accelerated wear and tear with regard to the HG issue. Both DR and my car gave done alot of track miles so some premature ageing no doubt. __________________ .